Misogyny and manacles: Wonder Woman’s surprising origin story

Like any superhero, Wonder Woman has a pretty complicated origin story.

Born out of both feminism and misogyny, Diana Prince was the creation of psychologist Dr. William Moulton Marston.

The good doctor had been bought in by DC (the famed comics powerhouse) to create a female superhero that would silence critics who called DC sexist and overly masculine.

Wonder Woman first appeared in 1941 and her unique brand of red white and blue heroism seemed like just the feminist super hero DC needed.

Original concept art for Wonder Woman, 1941
Original concept art for Wonder Woman

The creator of Wonder Woman, Dr. William Moulton Marston was a self confessed staunch feminist…just the kind of ‘feminist’ that might happily crack: ‘get back in the kitchen and make me a sandwich’ jokes (we’ll get to that!)

For his era Marsten was a new type of man, he talked about gender equality and believed in things like, female contraception. He also had some pretty radical feminist theories; believing that women were the superior sex, held back by being housewives.

He also led a progressive life for the time, living with both his wife, Elizabeth Holloway Marsten and lover, Olive Byrne. To avoid scandal, the trio told outsiders that Olive was their widowed sister…who just happened to give birth to Marsten’s kids.

gasp! gif.gif
Yeah. I’m sure that excuse totally flew…

Olive and Elizabeth were children of the suffrage movement, with Olive’s mother having both opened the USA’s first contraception clinic and been the first woman in the US to go on hunger strike as part of the fight for suffrage. Elizabeth meanwhile, was 1 of just 3 women to graduate in her law class.

Oliver Byre, Elizabeth Holloway and thier partner and Wonder Woman creator, Dr William Marsten
Olive, Elizabeth and Dr Marsten test out a lie detector  (which btw Elizabeth and Marsten created…)

On top of living with 2 incredibly strong women and holding some strong feminisit views, Marsten was pretty sexually liberal (which you probably got from the whole, living with both wife AND lover, thing) and an ardent member of the BDSM community.

ALL of this trickled into Wonder Woman.,,, Wonder Woman Tied Up

Believe me when I say, Wonder Woman spent a lot of her time tied up, manacled, chained and gagged.

Though she used her lasso of truth to pin down bad guys, her main source of weakness was being captured and tied up…because…reasons.

Marsten was always hands on with his work, BUT he was particularly specific around art work that showed Wonder Woman bound (no idea why…) Wonder Woman tied up

His heroine was seen trussed up and tied in almost every issue, with Marsten enthusiastically telling his editors:

‘Women enjoy submission’

But not all women did. Dorothy Roubicek, the first female editor at DC, took issue with Wonder Woman’s treatment. Marsten shrugged off her concerns, explaining that:

‘Of course I wouldn’t expect Miss Roubicek to understand this…has been in comics only 6 months or so, hasn’t she?’

eye roll
see what I meant about the sandwich jokes?

But despite all of this, Wonder Woman’s origin story remained revolutionary for the time.

Ok – Yes, part of the reason she leaves her home and comes to America, is because she falls in love with a man. BUT  he also goes because she’s heard that America is one of earths last hopes for female equality and that there’s a whole bunch of men trying to fuck that shit up; so naturally she needs to stop this through the medium of ass kicking.

Wonder Woman, Justice League gif.gif
A whole lot go ass kicking!!

Marsten said Wonder Woman was created for:

‘The new type of woman who should, I believe, rule the world.’

Now, lets all be in agreement, this is incredibly bad ass for the 1940s! Is it any wonder then that this new type of hero started to inspire girls to become real world heroes?

Smash the patricahy .gif

But all of this amazing arse kicking quickly stopped, when in 1947 Marsten died; his death was pretty much immediately followed by:

1) A psychological study which claimed violence in comics had a detrimental effect on youth. This led to comics putting more emphasis on soapy romantic storylines

2) The Dawn of the Silver Age of comics-which the internet has lovingly dubbed ‘super dickery’ for shit like this:

Jimmy Olsen adopted by Superman

Fun fact – I have this on my fridge

All this left Wonder Woman without a leader and easy prey to the super-dickery that was now gripping comic books.

And so Wonder Woman spending a lot of the 1950s writing a love advice column and dreaming of marriage, babies and a career as a model.

Wonder Woman, Sensation Comics, 1950s, an example of Super Dickery!
Wonder Woman, Queen of mind games

But that wasn’t to say Wonder Woman’s initial radicalism had been forgotten! The little girls she had inspired in the 40s were now all grown up and spear heading a new wave of feminism.

Wonder Woman was the cover star of feminist magazine Ms, in 1972. Gloria Stienham explained how vital Diana Prince was to this movement:

‘Wonder Woman symbolizes many of the values of the women’s culture that feminists are now trying to introduce into the mainstream: strength and self-reliance for women; sisterhood and mutual support among women; peacefulness and esteem for human life’

In 1975 Diana Prince set out to inspire a new generation of children, when she made her TV debut with hit live action series ‘Wonder Woman’.

Wonder Woman, 1975 TV Show, played by Linda Carter .gif
via giphy

But Wonder Woman was more than a TV show, it soon turned into a national debate as to what exactly was proper attire for saving the world – a debate which has continued to this day… just now on a global scale!

The most recent actress to play Wonder Woman, Gal Gadot, has faced plenty of criticism on her costume and physique – during a recent TV interview Gadot was told she was too skinny and flat chested to play Wonder Woman (no i don’t get this logic either).

Fortunately Gal Gadot can read a bitch out, and told the reporter that Amazon women of old actually only had one breast so they could have more space for their bow and arrow.

Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman.gif
Sassy and factually accurate, this girl is goals!  

Sadly this was far from the first time Diana Prince had to clap back.

In 1942 Wonder Woman was actually banned for a short time, all because of her dress attire!

Wonder Women’s knee high skirt, bodice and knee high boots were seen as incredibly skimpy and likely to induce wide spread ‘lesbianism’ among impressionable young girls. Bitch please

And Linda Carters 1970s Wonder Woman was as known for her tiny waist and low cut costume as she was her feminism and world saving.

In fact, just this year, Linda Carter had to slam sexism yet again, after Wonder Woman lost an honorary UN ambassador role, following complaints the character was too sexualised.

For those wondering, the UN Ambassador role Wonder Woman lost was to fight gender inequality…

sarcastic thumbs up.gif
yeah, that makes all the sense

But if we can learn anything from Wonder Woman it’s how to keep on busting walls down despite the adversity. Now with the mammoth success of her solo big screen debut, it looks like Wonder Woman is set to become a hero to a whole new generation of girls.

Born from both suffrage and misogyny, she opened the door for female super heroes in comics, sparked the imaginations of fledgling female leaders and is now kicking the door down on the future of female led blockbusters.

She may be in her 70’s, but Wonder Woman’s got a lot of fight left in her.

men are fools.gif
And sass. She has so much sass left.

This was interesting, where can i find out more? Jill Lepore has a fantastic book, The Secret History of Wonder Woman, which gives an in depth glimpse into how this iconic character was created and the effect her creator, Dr Masten, has on her. Worth checking out!

One thought on “Misogyny and manacles: Wonder Woman’s surprising origin story”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: